I loved the first ponytail so much I reordered the same one. The first one was shorter and curlier, which I loved. My bio-hair is very thin, not enough to put in a ponytail, so I removed the claw clip and just wrap the elastic around a claw clip in my hair. The second one looks like the picture on the website - about 5” longer and much fuller. Same color, which I love. The claw clip in this one holds much tighter so I won’t remove it. I’ve seen in reviews that there can be differences even when ordering the same wig. I’m going to keep it - I may end up cutting or bobby-pinning it shorter, but that’s fine. Love the color, and even my husband says it looks like real hair. It would look cute under a hat if I pull it through the back opening, which I could not do with the first wig, so…something new! I’m just starting my wig journey, I have 2 wigs now and a topper, but I still have enough hair in front that the ponytail/scrunchy buns work and are helping me get used to my helper-hair. I greatly appreciate Amazon’s return policy, it makes me much more confident when buying online, and sometimes you need to see something in person to know if it will work.